Godzilla: King of the Monsters is a picture of spectacular moments and considerable incoherence, a MonsterVerse entry that delivers the monster spectacle that Godzilla 2014's restraint withheld while replacing that film's atmospheric discipline with a human storyline of such bewildering motivation and such mechanical construction that the audience's investment in the monster battles depends entirely on the visual spectacle rather than on any stakes the human characters generate. Michael Dougherty's 2019 film is the franchise's most visually ambitious and its most dramatically compromised.
At a Glance
Director: Michael Dougherty
Runtime: 132 minutes
Starring: Kyle Chandler, Vera Farmiga, Millie Bobby Brown, Ken Watanabe, Charles Dance
Release: 2019
Critics Rating: ★★ (2/5 stars, spectacular monster battles undercut by incoherence)
Audience Rating: ★★★ (3/5 stars, divisive between those who prioritise monster spectacle and those who require coherence)
Review Breakdown
Plot
Following the events of Godzilla 2014, Monarch scientist Emma Russell, grieving the loss of her son in the San Francisco battle, has developed a device called the Orca that can communicate with the Titans. She allows eco-terrorist Alan Jonah to use it to awaken the Titans, believing that their activation will restore the planet's ecological balance. Her ex-husband Mark and their daughter Madison must stop her while Godzilla battles the newly awakened King Ghidorah, a three-headed alien Titan seeking to terraform Earth. The screenplay by Dougherty and Zach Shields introduces more Titans, more mythology, and more human characters than the franchise's previous entries without developing any of them with sufficient depth to give the monster battles their justification. Emma's motivation, the most consequential character decision in the MonsterVerse's history, is handled with a speed and a superficiality that makes her actions incomprehensible rather than tragic.
Characters
The human ensemble is the MonsterVerse's most problematic. Vera Farmiga's Emma is the most important failure, a character whose decision to unleash the Titans is presented as a reasoned ecological argument but whose reasoning is never developed with enough specificity to make it credible. Kyle Chandler's Mark is the most functionally drawn human character, a man of grief and competence whose opposition to Emma gives the human conflict its most legible dynamic. Millie Bobby Brown's Madison is the most effectively drawn young character, a teenager of resourcefulness and emotional complexity whose relationship with both parents gives the picture its most credible human stakes. Ken Watanabe's Serizawa is given the franchise's most emotionally significant sacrifice, and his final scene is the MonsterVerse's most moving human moment. Charles Dance's Jonah is the most effectively drawn human antagonist, a mercenary of menace and intelligence whose motivations are more clearly established than Emma's despite receiving considerably less screen time. Brown's Madison is the most promising new addition, a character of potential whose subsequent appearances in the franchise suggest that the MonsterVerse's creative team recognised what the picture's limitations had prevented her from fully achieving.
Tone
Dougherty pitches the picture at a register of operatic monster spectacle, abandoning Godzilla 2014's restraint in favour of a sustained visual assault of Titan battles, global devastation, and mythological revelation. The monster sequences are the franchise's most visually spectacular, and the battle between Godzilla and Ghidorah in the burning ruins of a Mexican city is the MonsterVerse's most cinematically impressive set-piece. The human sequences, by contrast, are the franchise's most inert, a series of exposition deliveries and motivation explanations that the pace does not give sufficient space to develop.
Meaning / Themes
The central ecological argument, that the Titans' activation would restore the planet's damaged biosphere, is the MonsterVerse's most ambitious thematic statement and its most mishandled. The idea that humanity's ecological damage has been so severe that only the Titans' intervention can repair it is a genuinely interesting extension of the franchise's established themes, but the failure to develop Emma's reasoning with sufficient depth means that the argument is presented as a villain's justification rather than as a moral position worthy of serious engagement.
Direction
Dougherty's direction is the MonsterVerse's most visually ambitious, staging monster battles of extraordinary scale and complexity with a grandeur that the franchise's previous entries had not attempted. His handling of the human sequences is considerably less assured, and the tonal oscillation between operatic monster spectacle and domestic family drama is the MonsterVerse's most jarring tonal problem. Bear McCreary's score is the franchise's most compositionally ambitious, incorporating Akira Ifukube's original Godzilla themes with a grandeur and a reverence that give the monster sequences their most effective musical passages.
Cultural Reception
King of the Monsters received mixed reviews on its release and was a commercial disappointment relative to its predecessor, grossing approximately $386 million worldwide against a significantly larger budget. Critics condemned the human storyline's incoherence while acknowledging the monster sequences' visual ambition, and it is now regarded as the MonsterVerse's most divisive entry, a picture whose spectacular moments are consistently cited alongside its failures as evidence of the franchise's unresolved tension between spectacle and story.
Who Should Watch
Viewers whose primary interest is in the MonsterVerse's monster spectacle and who are willing to accept incoherence as the price of visual ambition. King of the Monsters delivers its monster battles with a scale and a grandeur that the franchise's other entries have not matched, and those who engage with it primarily as a spectacle will find it the MonsterVerse's most satisfying entry in those terms.
Final Verdict: A picture of spectacular moments and considerable incoherence, the MonsterVerse's most visually ambitious entry and its most dramatically compromised. The monster battles are the franchise's most spectacular, McCreary's score is its most compositionally accomplished, and Serizawa's sacrifice is the MonsterVerse's most moving human moment. The human storyline's motivational incoherence is the franchise's most significant failure. It is a picture that is easier to admire in moments than to engage with as a coherent whole.
0 comments