Superman Returns is a film out of time. Released in 2006, Bryan Singer's long-gestating homage to the Richard Donner era arrives not as a reboot but as a continuation, a direct sequel to Superman II that sidesteps the Reeve sequels entirely and attempts to recapture the mythic grandeur of the 1978 original. The result is a film of emotional ambition, considerable craft, and frustrating dramatic inertia, one that is easier to admire than to love.
At a Glance
Director: Bryan Singer
Runtime: 154 minutes
Starring: Brandon Routh, Kate Bosworth, Kevin Spacey, James Marsden, Frank Langella, Parker Posey
Release: 2006
Critics Rating: ★★★ (3/5 stars, a flawed but sincere tribute)
Audience Rating: ★★★ (3/5 stars, admired more than loved)
Review Breakdown
Plot
Superman has been absent from Earth for five years, having travelled to the remnants of Krypton following reports of its possible survival. He returns to find the world has moved on: Lois Lane has a son, a fiance, and a Pulitzer Prize-winning editorial titled Why the World Doesn't Need Superman. Lex Luthor, freed from prison on a technicality, has stolen Kryptonian crystal technology from the Fortress of Solitude and hatched a plan to create a new continent that will render much of the existing world uninhabitable. Superman must reclaim his place in a world that no longer waited for him, while confronting the personal cost of his absence.
Characters
Brandon Routh is a revelation in a role that could easily have collapsed under the weight of comparison. His Clark Kent is warm, slightly awkward, and entirely convincing; his Superman carries a quiet melancholy that suits the elegiac tone perfectly. Routh does not attempt to impersonate Christopher Reeve so much as channel the same essential decency, and he succeeds more often than the picture's reception acknowledged at the time. Kate Bosworth's Lois Lane is the most significant miscasting: Bosworth is a capable actress, but she lacks the sharpness and authority that the role demands. Kevin Spacey's Lex Luthor is a more theatrical and menacing creation than Gene Hackman's, though the script ultimately reduces him to a real estate scheme that feels beneath the character's potential. Parker Posey provides welcome comic relief as Luthor's long-suffering companion Kitty Kowalski, and James Marsden brings quiet dignity to the thankless role of Richard White.
Tone
Reverential, melancholy, and at times moving. Singer's love for the Donner films is evident in every frame: the John Williams score, the visual grammar, the deliberate pacing. The picture is unafraid of silence and stillness in a genre that rarely permits either. Its weakness is that reverence occasionally tips into inertia. At 154 minutes, Superman Returns mistakes length for depth, and its central action set-piece, a spectacular sequence involving a crashing passenger jet, arrives so early that the remainder of the picture struggles to match it.
Meaning / Themes
Superman Returns is, beneath its superhero framework, a film about absence and return, about what it means to leave and what you find when you come back. Superman's five-year disappearance is framed as an act of hope that becomes an act of abandonment; the world did not stop, Lois did not wait, and the Man of Steel must reckon with the consequences of a choice he believed was right. The picture also gestures toward messianic imagery with considerable persistence: Superman as a Christ figure, sent by his father, sacrificing himself for humanity, rising again. The symbolism is not subtle, but it is earnestly deployed and gives the picture a thematic weight that distinguishes it from more straightforward superhero fare.
Direction
Singer directs with confidence and visual intelligence. The picture is beautifully shot, and the production design honours the Donner aesthetic without slavishly replicating it. The jet sequence is among the finest action set-pieces in superhero cinema. Where Singer falters is in pacing and structure; the second act loses momentum, and the climax resolves too quietly for a story of this scale. John Williams' original score is used throughout, supplemented by John Ottman's arrangements, and it remains one of the great superhero themes, lending the picture an emotional authority it might not otherwise sustain.
Cultural Reception
Superman Returns received a mixed critical and commercial reception on its release, with most reviewers praising Routh's performance and Singer's visual craft while noting its dramatic inertia and failure to generate the excitement of a franchise launch. Its underwhelming box office performance relative to its substantial budget effectively ended plans for a sequel and led directly to the eventual decision to reboot the franchise entirely with Man of Steel in 2013. Its reputation has improved modestly in the years since, with Routh's performance in particular receiving considerably more recognition than it did at the time of release.
Who Should Watch
Essential for fans of the Donner era and anyone interested in the history of Superman on screen. Those who approach it as a continuation of the 1978 original rather than a modern superhero film will find considerably more to appreciate. Viewers expecting the kinetic energy of contemporary comic book cinema will find it slow and sentimental. It rewards patience and a willingness to meet the picture on its own terms.
Final Verdict: A noble, melancholy, and frequently beautiful film that never quite becomes the classic it aspires to be. Brandon Routh is better than the picture deserved, Bryan Singer's direction is assured if overlong, and the whole enterprise is suffused with a love for what Superman represents. It is a film about returning to something you love and finding it changed. In that sense, it is the most honest Superman film ever made.
0 comments