The Lost World: Jurassic Park is a film that arrives burdened by one of cinema's most formidable predecessors and never quite finds a way to justify its existence on its own terms. Steven Spielberg's 1997 sequel is competently made and intermittently exciting, but it is also a film that mistakes scale for ambition and replaces the original's careful dramatic architecture with a series of increasingly disconnected set-pieces. It is not a disaster. It is something more frustrating: a film with the resources and talent to be genuinely good that settles for being merely adequate, and that settles for it without apparent discomfort.
At a Glance
Director: Steven Spielberg
Runtime: 129 minutes
Starring: Jeff Goldblum, Julianne Moore, Pete Postlethwaite, Arliss Howard, Richard Attenborough
Release: 1997
Critics Rating: ★★½ (2.5/5 stars, competent but uninspired)
Audience Rating: ★★★ (3/5 stars, watchable)
Review Breakdown
Plot
Ian Malcolm is recruited to join a research expedition to Isla Sorna, a second island where InGen bred its dinosaurs before transferring them to Jurassic Park. A rival corporate team arrives simultaneously to capture animals for a planned San Diego attraction, and the two groups' competing agendas destabilise an already dangerous environment. The screenplay struggles to generate the same narrative momentum as the original, partly because the premise requires the characters to be on the island without the original's elegant mechanism of the park's collapse, and partly because David Koepp's script is less interested in its human figures than in the logistics of moving them between set-pieces. The San Diego sequence in the final act is a tonal departure that feels grafted on from a different film entirely, a Godzilla pastiche that the preceding ninety minutes have not prepared the audience for and that the picture abandons as abruptly as it introduces it.
Characters
Goldblum's Malcolm is now the protagonist rather than the Greek chorus, and the shift does not entirely suit him. The character's function in the original was to articulate what the audience was thinking while the plot moved around him; as the lead, he is required to drive the action, and his philosophical detachment becomes an obstacle rather than an asset. Julianne Moore's Dr Sarah Harding is a capable field researcher whose competence is repeatedly undermined by the script's need to put her in danger, a tension the picture never resolves. Pete Postlethwaite's Roland Tembo is the most interesting human figure here, a big-game hunter of menace and personal code whose motivations are more complex than the narrative gives him credit for. His decision to walk away at the end, having achieved his goal and found it hollow, is the most quietly affecting moment in the picture, and it belongs to a better film than the one surrounding it. Goldblum carries the picture on the strength of his established screen presence, but the material does not give him enough to work with. Postlethwaite brings weight and specificity to Tembo that the script does not fully earn.
Tone
The picture oscillates between Spielberg's characteristic wonder and a harder-edged action register without fully committing to either. The set-pieces are technically accomplished but lack the spatial clarity and patient construction that made the original's sequences so enduringly effective. The trailer-over-the-cliff sequence is the most sustained piece of tension, a inventive piece of physical filmmaking that goes on considerably longer than its dramatic content can support. The raptor sequence in the long grass is the most purely effective individual passage, a demonstration of sound design and negative space that recalls the original's best work and suggests what a more disciplined production might have achieved throughout.
Meaning / Themes
The picture gestures at ideas about corporate exploitation and the commodification of nature, positioning InGen's capture operation as a critique of the entertainment industry's appetite for spectacle at any cost. These themes are handled with considerably less rigour than the original's treatment of scientific hubris, however, and the San Diego sequence, which might have been the most pointed satirical statement, is played for monster-movie thrills rather than thematic consequence. The picture has less to say than its predecessor and says it less interestingly, which is a particular disappointment given that Crichton's source novel had considerably more to offer on the subject of corporate irresponsibility than the screenplay chose to use.
Direction
Spielberg's technical command is never in doubt, and the picture contains individual sequences of craft. The raptor sequence in the long grass is the most purely effective passage, a demonstration of sound design and negative space that recalls the original's best work. The T. rex attack on the trailers is staged with a physical imagination and a sense of scale that few directors could match. Where Spielberg falters is in the connective tissue between these sequences, the character scenes and expository passages that give a film its emotional weight and that here feel perfunctory. John Williams returns with a score that is serviceable rather than memorable, providing adequate support without the thematic architecture that distinguished his work on the original.
Cultural Reception
The Lost World received mixed reviews on its release but was a major commercial success, grossing over $618 million worldwide to become one of the highest-grossing films of 1997. Critics acknowledged Spielberg's technical command and Postlethwaite's performance while noting the screenplay's weaknesses relative to the original. It is now regarded as a competent but uninspired sequel whose commercial success demonstrated the franchise's box office durability even when creative quality declined. Tembo is consistently cited as the series' most interesting human character outside the original film, and the raptor sequence in the long grass is frequently listed among the franchise's finest individual set-pieces.
Who Should Watch
Franchise completists and viewers with a tolerance for technically proficient but dramatically thin blockbusters. The Lost World has enough individual moments of craft to reward patient viewing, and Postlethwaite's performance alone justifies the time investment for those interested in what the series might have done with a more complex human antagonist.
Final Verdict: A competent but uninspired sequel that demonstrates how difficult it is to replicate the conditions that made the original work. Postlethwaite's Tembo is a character worth the price of admission on his own, and the raptor sequence in the long grass is the franchise's second-best individual set-piece. Everything else is a diminishing return on a film that did not need a follow-up and that never finds a compelling reason to exist beyond the commercial logic that produced it.
0 comments